i don’t want to cut those terrorists any slack. They’re murderers and we ought to bring them to justice, every one of them. Swift justice. But here’s the thing. There’s this word, “Islamofascism,” and every time I hear it I wonder if there isn’t some kind of Godwin’s law being broken.
Islamofascism, fairly rolls off the tongue, and we know fascism is the worst thing ever so it makes good sense to tie Islam to it so we can think that Islam is, well - you know….
Here’s some of what the Wikipedia says about the term, and it pretty much speaks my mind…
Islamofascism is a neologism and political epithet used to compare the ideological or operational characteristics of certain modern Islamist movements with European fascist movements of the early 20th century, neofascist movements, or totalitarianism. Organizations that have been labeled Islamofascist include Al-Qaeda, the current Iranian government,[1] the Taliban, the Muslim Brotherhood, Hamas, and Hezbollah. None label themselves fascist, however, and critics of the term argue that associating the religion of Islam with fascism is both offensive and historically inaccurate…. [emphasis mine]
The more widely used term for politicized strains of Islam that seek to place governments in Muslim countries under the guidance of Sharia law is Islamist.
Islamists do not advocate corporatism, an important component of “classic” fascist governments in Italy and Germany….
Whenever I read or hear the term Islamofascism I think someone is trying to influence me big time. It’s a large, lazy word that reeks of guilt by association. It polarizes people in order to justify continuing the Bush crusade. Let’s only use it when it’s meaningful (like never, since the corporatist state, oddly enough, is far more emergent in the crusaders’ countries than the Islamists’ and the whole thing reeks of Orwellian double-speak).
{ 8 comments… read them below or add one }
alan herrell - the head lemur 06.15.06 at 10:39
That because they don’t have PR
http://theheadlemur.typepad.com/ravinglunacy/2006/06/when_pr_goes_so.html
or they could have and it’s bad.
EuroYank 06.16.06 at 1:28
Big Brotherism is a much kinder word. There is no fascism in it, though it be fascist. Its not in your face. It rolls off the tongue easily. Big Brotherism is a word that gives you a warm feeling. A friendly word that wants to help you and be your guiding hand. I suggest that when trying to define a fascist or fascism or islamfascism etc try Islam Big Brotherism. It gently rolls of the tongue and does not seem to be offensive.
Brian 06.16.06 at 7:54
I don’t use the I-word myself. But were (say) LGF to start using the term Islamist to replace Islamofascism I can see a a lot more people getting upset.
To wit: “You’re using the term to brush an entire relgion!”
LGF heaves a great sigh and mutters about how there is just no pleasing some people.
Frank Paynter 06.16.06 at 8:51
LGF stands for “little green footballs,” a right-wing screed with a petro-terror agenda. The fact that Charles Johnson uses the term underscores my point. I visited Johnson’s blog and searched for the terms “Islamist” and “Islamofascist.” I inferred from a quick scan that Johnson will use the former when quoting source material, but uses the latter when ginning up his own hate fueled rhetoric (or when quoting other intolerant sources).
J. Alva Scruggs 06.16.06 at 11:31
I can sympathize with the LGFers. For years I’ve insisted that Christians are fascists. There’s plenty of evidence to support that. Italy, Christian nation, hello?? Germany, Christian nation, hello?? But people greet my explanations with contempt nevertheless. They don’t even want to debate me :’-( You can tell they can’t take the truth! Sometimes they throw things at me. The pies are pretty good, actually, but I could live without the scorn that accompanies them.
Brian 06.16.06 at 11:40
Doesn’t everyone know what LGF stands for?
Maybe not. I was working a few nights ago, ran into a good bit of data on the web, wanted to save it. A few clicks later bang it’s in del.icio.us/bdunbar
The guy I was working with had never heard of del.icio.us. And he’s a fairly clued in guy in the tech world. Interesting.
Frank Paynter 06.16.06 at 12:25
People who know who Hinderaker is, probably know Charles Johnson too, but our political punditry is so locked into an echo chamber on both the left and the right that typically I think those on one side won’t recognize any but the most egregiously vile public personalities from the other. Take Glen Reynolds… PLEASE! (hehe)
Brian 06.16.06 at 2:00
I work at keeping a balance. I generally don’t subscribe to busy-busy blogs like LGF or Kos not because of politics but because it’s like trying to drink from a firehose. Aything really good the people I do read will link to it anyway.
But yes, a balance.